4.0 KiB
4.0 KiB
SQA Review Record: DCD-003 Start the script as a global command, and DCD-002
Metadata
| Key | Value |
|---|---|
| ID | RC-028 |
| CrossReference | DCD-003, QC-DCD-001, DCD-002, DCD-001, SD-002 |
Version History
| Date | Status | Author | Reviewer | Change | Commit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-10-07 | Proposed | Jens Tirsvad Nielsen | S02 | Initial version | 1cd27f7 |
Artifact Under Review
- Instance reviewed: DCD-003, and the changes it causes in DCD-002.
- Checklist used: QC-DCD-001.
- Review date: 2026-10-07
Checklist Results (QC-DCD-001)
| # | Criterion | Status | Evidence/Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | SOLID principles applied; no god classes with excessive responsibilities | Pass | Three small classes with one responsibility each; Launcher has no data and no logic beyond finding folders. |
| 2 | Visibility markers correct and consistent (+ public, - private, # protected) |
Pass | + for operations, - for attributes. |
| 3 | Relationships correctly distinguished: Association vs Aggregation vs Composition vs Dependency | Pass | Composition Run to Checkout and WorkingFolder; dependencies for creation; one association Launcher to ProjectCreator. |
| 4 | Multiplicities and navigability specified on all associations | Pass | The Launcher to ProjectCreator association had no multiplicity in the first draft; "1" --> "1" was added in DCD-003 and DCD-002 during this review. |
| 5 | Applied design patterns are annotated explicitly (e.g. Singleton, Factory, Strategy) | Pass | Controller and Information Expert are annotated. |
| 6 | Method signatures are traceable to Operation Contracts and/or design Sequence Diagrams | Pass | Method Traceability maps every method to OC-002 or SD-002. |
| 7 | Class names and structure remain consistent with the Domain Model concepts they refine | Pass | Launcher refines Command Link, Checkout and Working Folder keep their names; the table says why Command Link has no class of its own. |
| 8 | No circular dependencies between classes/packages unless explicitly justified | Pass | Launcher depends on the others and none depends on it. |
Change checks on the other artifacts
| Artifact | Change | Status | Evidence/Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| DCD-002 | Launcher, Checkout, WorkingFolder; ProjectCreator.startProjectCreation takes the checkout, the working folder and the two paths |
Pass with a note | The signature differs from DCD-001, OC-001 and SD-001, which show startProjectCreation() with no parameters. The scoped views of UC-001 were not changed; DCD-002 is the consolidated truth and records the new signature and its source in Method Traceability. |
Overall Verdict
Go-with-conditions — DCD-003 meets every mandatory criterion, but the consolidated DCD-002 and the scoped views of UC-001 disagree on the signature of startProjectCreation. The status stays Proposed until the action item is closed. Drafted by Claude Code for S02 against the checklist; the author and reviewer are the same person for now (as in the earlier records). The verdict takes effect, and the Version History rows of the reviewed documents change to Accepted, only when S02 confirms it.
Action Items
| Action | Owner | Due |
|---|---|---|
Decide whether OC-001, SD-001 and DCD-001 get the new startProjectCreation parameters too, or are kept as the scoped view of UC-001 with a note that DCD-002 supersedes the signature |
S01 | Before MIL-007 starts |