054-speed-calc-decorator/docs/sqa/reviews/rc-008-wiki-mil-003.md

SQA Review Record

Metadata

Key	Value
ID	RC-008
CrossReference	MIL-003, QC-WIKI-001

Version History

Date	Status	Author	Reviewer	Change	Commit
2026-11-06	Proposed	Jens Tirsvad Nielsen	AI as stand-in for S01	Initial version	0227b10

---

Artifact Under Review

• Instance reviewed: MIL-003 deliverable, the wiki in docs/wiki/ (18 pages and _Sidebar.md)
• Checklist used: QC-WIKI-001 (framework/qc/docs/wiki/ holds the framework's own wiki, not a checklist, so no second checklist applies)
• Scope: full review, 1 round, no defects found. Page content in Danish and Bahasa Malaysia was read for translation quality (the language checks of QC-LANG-001 apply to the page text); no language reviewer other than the stand-in
• Language and domain: en, da, ms / it (wiki pages)
• Language reviewer: none (the stand-in reads the three languages; S01 confirmed the language checks for MIL-003 in RC-005)
• Mode: autonomous, not independent (reviewer AI as stand-in for S01)

Checks were run with a script that compares the pages: fenced code blocks, inline code spans and image URLs of each -da and -ms page against English (all identical), the language line of all 18 pages against the expected text, and every internal link against the files in the folder.

Checklist Results

#	Criterion	Status	Evidence/Notes
1	_Sidebar.md exists	Pass	Present
2	Bold title, then one English list, Home first	Pass	**Speed Calc Decorator**, then Home, Setup, Steps 1 to 4
3	List links every English page, no dead link	Pass	6 links, 6 English pages, all targets exist
4	Related only when related wikis exist	Pass	No related wikis; no such section
5	Languages last, one line per language in its language, linking to Home	Pass	English: [Home](Home), Dansk: [Hjem](Home-da), Bahasa Malaysia: [Utama](Home-ms)
6	List not repeated per language	Pass	Listed once
7	Generated sidebar carries a generator comment	N-A	Written by hand, not generated
8	Languages line on each page (Optional)	Pass	See criterion 11
9	English plus the PO language	Pass	English, Danish and Bahasa Malaysia; the Business Case names da and ms
10	Page sets identical	Pass	6 pages x 3 languages
11	Language line on every page, current language bold, links to same page	Pass	18 of 18 match the expected line; targets exist
12	Naming <Page>-<code>.md, English unsuffixed	Pass	-da, -ms suffixes, BCP 47
13	Code, commands, file names, IDs stay English	Pass	Code blocks, inline code spans and image URLs identical to English in all 12 translations. Code comments such as # seconds since Jan 1st, 1970 stay English as code
14	Checked on the published wiki after the change	Pass	2026-11-06, after the merge and the publish workflow: the wiki API lists 19 pages (6 pages x 3 languages and _Sidebar); all 18 pages return HTTP 200 on the host; the Step-3-Timing-Wrapper-ms page links to the sibling pages in all three languages; _Sidebar and the step-1 screenshot URL return 200. Checked by the AI as stand-in for S01 (an objective check, not a language judgement)
15	Layout change made in generator and checklist (Optional)	N-A	No layout rule changed
16	Folder flat	Pass	All 19 files directly in docs/wiki/, no subfolder

Further findings:

• Internal links: every non-external link in all pages points to an existing file in the same language (content links keep the language suffix; only the language line crosses languages, as intended).
• Screenshots: the 4 image URLs (raw/branch/main/docs/screenshots/...) are the same in all languages and the 4 files exist in docs/screenshots/. The URLs resolve only after merge to main, which is part of criterion 14.
• Danish and Bahasa Malaysia read correctly and idiomatically; technical terms (decorator, closure, wrapper, float) are used consistently, and "What we gained" is rendered as "Hvad vi lærte" and "Apa yang kita peroleh". No errors found, nothing edited.

MIL-003 Go criteria (verdict part excluded)

#	Criterion	Status	Evidence
1	Flat; each English page has -da and -ms	Pass	Criteria 10 and 16
2	Each page starts with the language switch line	Pass	Criterion 11; the line follows the title heading, as in the checklist example
3	Each step page shows its screenshot and a "What we gained" section	Pass	Steps 1 to 4 in all three languages have an image and the section (also Setup)
4	Sidebar shape	Pass	Criteria 2 to 6
5	Review against QC-WIKI-001 is a Go	Pass	This record; see the verdict

Overall Verdict

Go. All Mandatory criteria pass and no defect was found. Criterion 14 was Pending until the wiki was published; it passed on 2026-11-06 after the merge (see its row). Mode: autonomous, not independent; reviewer AI as stand-in for S01.

Action Items

Action	Owner	Due
Closed 2026-11-06: published wiki checked (criterion 14)	S01	2026-11-09

---